| Date | V | Opponents | F-A | Scorers | Pos | Att | GK | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 | 11 | Sub 1 | Sub 2 | Sub 3 | Unused | Ref | |
| 05-Aug-23 | H | Warrington Town | 0-4 | 24 | 1522 | Renshaw | Thomson | Doyle | Flowers | Anson | Evans | Quansah | Bainbridge | Hmami | Carver | Walton | Watson 6 | Morgan 2 | C Heath 9 | Sass & McMillan | H Conley | ||
| 12-Aug-23 | A | Alfreton Town | 1-3 | Quansah | 23 | 429 | Renshaw | Quansah | Sass | Flowers | Anson | Bainbridge | Watson | Morgan | C Heath | Hmami | Walton | Billington 8 | F Heath 10 | Evans, Doyle & McMillan | D Rogers | ||
| 15-Aug-23 | A | Spennymoor Town | 1-5 | Evans (Pen) | 24 | 1091 | Renshaw | Thomson | Doyle | Flowers | Sass | Evans | Watson | Bainbridge | Quansah | Carver | Walton | F Heath 8 | C Heath 10 | Anson, Billington & McMillan | Z Kettle | ||
| 19-Aug-23 | H | Boston United | 0-2 | 24 | 801 | Renshaw | Thomson | Doyle | Flowers | Anson | F Heath | Watson | Morgan | Hmami | Carver | Walton | Quansah 2 | C Heath 7 | Evans, Sass, McMillan | O Noonan | |||
| 26-Aug-23 | A | Brackley Town | 0-0 | 24 | 603 | Renshaw | Quansah | Doyle | Flowers | Anson | F Heath | Hmami | Morgan | Costello | Carver | Walton | Watson 9 | Bainbridge 6 | Evans 7 | Sass & McKerny | G Laflin | ||
| 28-Aug-23 | H | Chorley | 0-2 | 24 | 1633 | Renshaw | Quansah | Sass | Flowers | Anson | Bainbridge | Hmami | Morgan | Costello | Carver | Walton | Watson 9 | Doyle 3 | Evans, F Heath & McKerny | J Maskrey | |||
| 02-Sep-23 | A | Hereford | 1-0 | Carver | 24 | 2259 | Renshaw | Quansah | Doyle | Flowers | Anson | F Heath | Watson | Morgan | Hmami | Carver | Walton | Bainbridge 6 | Costello 10 | C Heath 9 | Sass & McMillan | R Ely | |
| 05-Sep-23 | H | Scarborough Athletic | 3-1 | Carver, Watson(2) | 23 | 831 | Renshaw | Quansah | Doyle | Flowers | Anson | F Heath | Watson | Morgan | O’Neill | Carver | Walton | Bainbridge 9 | Costello 6 | C Heath 7 | Sass & McMillan | D Brown | |
| 09-Sep-23 | A | King’s Lynn Town | 4-1 | Carver(3), Doyle | 19 | 826 | Renshaw | Quansah | Doyle | Flowers | Anson | F Heath | Watson | Morgan | O’Neill | Carver | Holmes | Costello 11 | Mariette 9 | Sass 3 | Evans & McMillan | J Crofts | |
| 16-Sep-23 | A | Morpeth Town FAC 2Q | 0-3 | * | 272 | Renshaw | Quansah | Sass | Flowers | Anson | F Heath | Watson | Morgan | O’Neill | Carver | Holmes | Evans 3 | Walton 9 | Mariette 5 | Thomson, Bainbridge, Costello, , McMillan | B Tomlinson | ||
| 23-Sep-23 | H | Tamworth | 0-0 | 19 | 1137 | Renshaw | Quansah | Doyle | Flowers | Evans | Holmes | Watson | Morgan | Hmami | Carver | Walton | O’Neill 6 | Mariette 9 | Thomson, F Heath & McMillan | L Dawson | |||
| 07-Oct-23 | A | Bishop’s Stortford | 3-2 | O’Neill, Hmami, Bainbridge | 17 | 621 | Renshaw | Quansah | Doyle | Flowers | Evans | Holmes | Watson | Morgan | Hmami | Carver | O’Neill | F Heath 11 | Bainbridge 9 | Thomson 10 | McMillan | M Conn | |
| 14-Oct-23 | H | Gloucester City | 2-1 | Holmes, Flowers | 12 | 1327 | Renshaw | Quansah | Doyle | Flowers | Evans | Holmes | Watson | Morgan | Hmami | Carver | O’Neill | Bainbridge 7 | Burgess 11 | Thomson 6 | F Heath & McMillan | O Noonan | |
| 17-Oct-23 | H | Squires Gate (LCT2) | 3-1 | Holmes, Burgess, Bainbridge | * | 244 | McMillan | Thomson | Doyle | F Heath | Anson | Evans | Watson | Bainbridge | Holmes | Burgess | O’Neill | Quansah 3 | Morgan 10 | Carver 8 | Renshaw & Hmami | R Aspinall | |
| 21-Oct-23 | A | Peterborough Sports | 0-2 | 15 | 321 | Renshaw | Quansah | Doyle | Flowers | Evans | Holmes | Burgess | Morgan | Hmami | Carver | O’Neill | Bainbridge 11 | Watson 7 | Anson, Thomson & McMillan | I Searle | |||
| 24-Oct-23 | H | Chester | 0-2 | 19 | 1835 | Renshaw | Quansah | Doyle | Flowers | Evans | Holmes | Burgess | Morgan | Hmami | Carver | Bainbridge | Watson 3 | O’Neill 6 | Thomson 5 | F Heath & McMillan | M Mcquillan | ||
| 28-Oct-23 | H | Banbury United | 0-1 | 20 | 996 | Renshaw | Thomson | Doyle | Flowers | Evans | Holmes | Watson | Morgan | O’Neill | Carver | Bainbridge | Burgess 3 | Quansah 9 | F Heath 7 | Kilcullen & McMillan | B Robinson | ||
| 04-Nov-23 | A | Rushall Olympic | 3-2 | Carver, Bainbridge, Watson | 15 | 426 | Renshaw | Thomson | Doyle | Quansah | Evans | Holmes | Burgess | Morgan | O’Neill | Carver | Bainbridge | Watson 10 | F Heath 9 | Kilcullen & McMillan | G Thomas | ||
| 07-Nov-23 | A | Blyth Spartans | 3-3 | Bainbridge, Holmes, Watson | 17 | 435 | Renshaw | Thomson | Doyle | Flowers | Quansah | Hmami | Burgess | Morgan | Bennett | Carver | Bainbridge | Holmes 7 | Watson 9 | O’Neill 10 | Evans & McMillan | L Dawson | |
| 11-Nov-23 | H | South Shields | 1-0 | Evans (Pen) | 12 | 1165 | Renshaw | Quansah | Doyle | Flowers | Evans | Hmami | Holmes | Morgan | Bennett | Carver | Bainbridge | O’Neill 6 | Thomson 7 | F Heath 9 | Kilcullen & McMillan | D Brown | |
| 14-Nov-23 | H | Farsley Celtic | 1-1 | Holmes | 12 | 701 | Renshaw | Quansah | Doyle | Flowers | Evans | Hmami | Holmes | Morgan | Bennett | Watson | Bainbridge | O’Neill 11 | Thomson, Anson, F Heath & McMillan | W Davis | |||
| 18-Nov-23 | H | South Shields(FAT2) | 4-0 | O’Neill, Anson, Watson, Evans(pen) | * | 761 | Renshaw | Thomson | Doyle | Hmami | Anson | Evans | Watson | Morgan | Bennett | O’Neill | Bainbridge | F Heath 8 | Flowers 5 | Kilcullen 10 | Quansah & McMillan | S Taylor | |
| 21-Nov-23 | A | Scunthorpe United | 0-1 | 15 | 3035 | Renshaw | Thomson | Doyle | Flowers | Evans | F Heath | Watson | Morgan | O’Neill | Hmami | Holmes | Billington 9 | Quansah 11 | Anson, Kilcullen & McMillan | L Griffiths | |||
| 25-Nov-23 | A | Buxton | 1-0 | O’Neill | 11 | 663 | Renshaw | Thomson | Doyle | Flowers | Evans | Hmami | Watson | Morgan | Bennett | O’Neill | Holmes | Anson 5 | Carver 10 | F Heath 7 | Quansah & McMillan | H Jones | |
| 05-Dec-23 | A | Runcorn Linnets(LSC2) | 1-4 | Burgess | * | 264 | McMillan | Quansah | Sass | Flowers | Anson | Bainbridge | O’Neill | Morgan | Billington | Carver | Holmes | Bennett7, F Heath5, Burgess9, Walton11, Thomson8, Renshaw(U)Hmama(U) | L Corrigan | ||||
| 09-Dec-23 | A | Chesterfield(FAT3) | 1-6 | Bennett | * | 2156 | Renshaw | Thomson | Doyle | Flowers | Quansah | Bainbridge | Watson | Morgan | Bennett | Hmami | Holmes | Carver 6 | Walton 11 | O’Neill 9 | F Heath, Burgess, Kilcullen, McMillan | M Crusham | |
| 16-Dec-23 | A | Tamworth | 0-4 | 18 | 1100 | Renshaw | Thomson | Quansah | Flowers | Squires | Hmami | Holmes | Morgan | Bennett | Carver | Walton | Bainbridge 6 | O’Neill 11 | F Heath, Sass, McMillan | M Burgin | |||
| 23-Dec-23 | H | King’s Lynn Town | 0-4 | 19 | 1016 | Renshaw | Thomson | Doyle | Flowers | Squires | Philliskirk | Hmami | Morgan | Bennett | Holmes | Walton | Carver 7 | Bainbridge, F Heath, Quansah, McMillan | M Scholes | ||||
| 26-Dec-23 | A | Curzon Ashton | 2-3 | Holmes, Flowers | 19 | 482 | Renshaw | Thomson | Doyle | Flowers | Squires | Philliskirk | Burgess | Morgan | Bennett | Holmes | Walton | Hmami 7 | Carver 11 | Bainbridge 3 | Quansah & McMillan | M Mcquillan | |
| 01-Jan-24 | H | Curzon Ashton | 0-3 | 19 | 1156 | Renshaw | Thomson | Bainbridge | Flowers | Squires | Philliskirk | Burgess | Morgan | Bennett | Holmes | Walton | Doyle 5 | Carver 7 | Quansah, Hmami & McMillan | D Rogers | |||
| 06-Jan-24 | A | Gloucester City | 2-2 | Bennett, Walton | 20 | 1012 | Renshaw | Thomson | Doyle | Flowers | Squires | Philliskirk | Hmami | Morgan | Holmes | Carver | Walton | Burgess 7 | Bennett 9 | Quansah, Bainbridge & McMillan | B Robinson | ||
| 09-Jan-24 | H | Darlington | 2-0 | Bennett 2 | 17 | 647 | Renshaw | Thomson | Doyle | Flowers | Squires | Philliskirk | Burgess | Morgan | Bennett | Carver | Walton | Hmami 8 | F Heath 7 | Holmes 10 | Quansah & McMillan | J Maskrey | |
| 27-Jan-24 | H | Alfreton Town | 2-3 | Carver 2 | 20 | 864 | Renshaw | Thomson | Doyle | Flowers | Arthur | Philliskirk | Burgess | Morgan | Bennett | Carver | Walton | Hmami 7 | Russ 10 | Quansah, Holmes, McMillan | L Dawson | ||
| 03-Feb-24 | A | Boston United | 0-3 | 21 | 1676 | Renshaw | Thomson | Doyle | Flowers | Arthur | Philliskirk | Burgess | Morgan | Bennett | Carver | Walton | Hmami 7 | F Heath 9 | Russ 6 | Quansah & McMillan | J Bancroft | ||
| 06-Feb-24 | H | Spennymoor Town | 1-2 | Hmami | 21 | 512 | Renshaw | Thomson | Doyle | Flowers | Arthur | Philliskirk | Burgess | Morgan | Hmami | Carver | Walton | Bennett 9 | Russ 10 | Archer 8 | Quansah & McMillan | G Thomas | |
| 10-Feb-24 | H | Brackley Town | 3-1 | Flowers, Hmami, Archer | 19 | 754 | Renshaw | Hockenhull | Doyle | Flowers | Arthur | Philliskirk | Russ | Heath | Hmami | Carver | Walton | Bennett 7 | Thomson 8 | Archer 5 | Quansah & McMillan | M Mcquillan | |
| 17-Feb-24 | A | Chorley | 0-3 | 20 | 1644 | Renshaw | Thomson | Doyle | Flowers | Arthur | Hockenhull | Lloyd | Hmami | Bennett | Philliskirk | Walton | Archer 5 | Burgess 7 | Quansah. Morgan & McMillan | W Davis | |||
| 20-Feb-24 | A | Scarborough Athletic | 1-0 | Walton | 18 | 1378 | Renshaw | Hockenhull | Doyle | Quansah | Arthur | Philliskirk | Lloyd | Morgan | Hmami | Carver | Walton | Thomson 3 | Burgess 7 | Flowers 9 | Archer & Bennett | D Jones | |
| 24-Feb-24 | H | Hereford | 1-2 | Carver | 18 | 1208 | Renshaw | Hockenhull | Thomson | Quansah | Arthur | Philliskirk | Lloyd | Morgan | Hmami | Carver | Walton | Flowers 11 | Bennett 8 | Burgess 6 | Archer & Russ | H Warner | |
| 27-Feb-24 | H | Bacup Boro(LCT QF) | 4-0 | Lloyd 2, Archer, Arthur | * | 245 | McMillan | Thomson | Quansah | Arthur | Hockenhull | Burgess | Lloyd | Morgan | Archer | Russ | Yao | Bennett 11 | Anson 4 | Philliskirk 8 | Hmami & Renshaw | A Beckett | |
| 02-Mar-24 | H | Peterborough Sports | 0-0 | 19 | 805 | Renshaw | Thomson | Doyle | Arthur | Hockenhull | Quansah | Hmami | Morgan | Bennett | Carver | Philliskirk | Archer 8 | Russ 9 | Flowers, Anson & McMillan | B Robinson | |||
| 05-Mar-24 | A | Warrington Town | 4-0 | Bennett, Carver, Anson | 18 | 1421 | Renshaw | Thomson | Doyle | Arthur | Hockenhull | Quansah | Hmami | Morgan | Bennett | Carver | Philliskirk | Anson 8 | Russ 9 | Flowers, Archer & McMillan | L Corbett | ||
| 09-Mar-24 | A | Banbury United | 1-0 | Carver | 17 | 636 | Renshaw | Thomson | Doyle | Arthur | Hockenhull | Quansah | Hmami | Russ | Bennett | Carver | Philliskirk | Archer 8 | Flowers 9 | Billington 10 | Evans & McMillan | C Jones | |
| 12-Mar-24 | A | Chester | 1-0 | Bennett | 16 | 1739 | Renshaw | Thomson | Doyle | Arthur | Hockenhull | Quansah | Hmami | Lloyd | Bennett | Carver | Philliskirk | Anson 2 | Burgess 7 | Russ 10 | Flowers & McMillan | R Claussen | |
| 16-Mar-24 | H | Blyth Spartans | 2-3 | Lloyd, Bennett | 16 | 977 | Renshaw | Quansah | Doyle | Arthur | Hockenhull | Anson | Burgess | Lloyd | Bennett | Carver | Philliskirk | Heath 4 | Russ 3 | Flowers, Evans & McMillan | D Brown | ||
| 20-Mar-24 | N | Bamber Bridge(LCTSF) | 1-3 | Anson | * | 311 | McMillan | Quansah | Doyle | Flowers | Anson | Evans | Lloyd | Hmami | Russ | Burgess | Heath | Carver 6 | Hockenhull, Philliskirk, Bennett & Renshaw | N Cox | |||
| 23-Mar-24 | H | Buxton | 2-2 | Lloyd(pen) Bennett | 18 | 1246 | McMillan | Quansah | Doyle | Arthur | Hockenhull | Anson | Lloyd | Burgess | Bennett | Carver | Philliskirk | Russ 5 | Flowers, Evans & Heath | T Wilson | |||
| 26-Mar-24 | H | Bishop’s Stortford | 4-1 | Hmami, Carver, Bennett, Philliskirk | 15 | 607 | McMillan | Quansah | Doyle | Arthur | Hockenhull | Anson | Lloyd | Hmami | Bennett | Carver | Philliskirk | Burgess 7 | Russ 9 | Flowers, Evans, Heath | O Noonan | ||
| 29-Mar-24 | A | Farsley Celtic | 0-0 | 15 | 523 | McMillan | Quansah | Doyle | Flowers | Arthur | Anson | Lloyd | Hmami | Bennett | Carver | Philliskirk | Hockenhull 5 | Russ 6 | Evans, Heath, Billington | L Hible | |||
| 01-Apr-24 | H | Scunthorpe United | 0-1 | 15 | 1540 | McMillan | Quansah | Doyle | Flowers | Hockenhull | Anson | Lloyd | Hmami | Russ | Heath | Philliskirk | Lockett 10 | Arthur 7 | Evans, Billington Renshaw | J Chadwick | |||
| 06-Apr-24 | A | Darlington | 0-2 | 15 | 1778 | Renshaw | Quansah | Doyle | Flowers | Arthur | Anson | Lloyd | Hmami | Russ | Bennett | Philliskirk | Morgan 5 | Lockett 9 | Heath, Hockenhull, McMillan | D Brown | |||
| 13-Apr-24 | H | Rushall Olympic | 3-0 | Walton 2, Arthur | 16 | 1311 | Renshaw | Quansah | Doyle | Flowers | Arthur | Anson | Hmami | Morgan | Philliskirk | Bennett | Walton | Russ 11 | Heath, Evans, Lockett, McMillan | H Jones | |||
| 20-Apr-24 | A | South Shields | 0-3 | 17 | 2779 | Renshaw | Quansah | Doyle | Flowers | Anson | Philliskirk | Lloyd | Morgan | Russ | Hmami | Walton | Thomson 2 | Heath 8 | Evans 7 | McMillan | C Jones | ||